As the monuments tumble
Dec. 8th, 2024 11:46 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
This has been a weekend blissfully free of any plan or activity. Originally, the idea had been to go to the annual street fair in Cambridge, which is held along one long road, lined with restaurants, cafes, and shops (mainly things like South Asian, East Asian, Eastern European, and Middle Eastern grocery stores) on the first Saturday of December. However, the storm put paid to that — the event was cancelled due to the safety risk — and the cancelled plans and weather led to two days of much needed rest at home.
I finished another book in my Benjamin January reread, worked on Yuletide stuff, watched biathlon with Matthias, and spent ages writing and replying to long comments on Dreamwidth. It was an utterly lazy Saturday, with no gym (since I hadn't booked the classes in expectation of being in Cambridge during that time), and no time outside the house apart from a quick run to the bakery first thing (before the storm began) to get pastries. By about midday, the storm had arrived in earnest, but it wasn't too bad in this part of the world — just lashing rain, and strong winds. I know my friends in Ireland, Wales, and the west of England had it much worse, including at least one friend in Wales who lost power briefly, but for us in the east, it was basically just a cosy day at home.
The weather's still pretty miserable here, so I'm not planning to do much today — a longer yoga class after I've written this post, a bit more comfort rereading, and slow-cooking tonight's dinner for most of the afternoon. Otherwise, I will carry on what I've also been doing for much of yesterday, and the previous week, which is glue myself to updates and analysis of all the extraordinary political events taking place around the world.
Initially I was keeping a fairly close eye on what was happening in South Korea, Romania and Georgia (the country, not the US state). This Observer editorial is fairly broad-brush and simplistic, but covers the main points, while this longer essay by Timothy Snyder is a rather depressing comparison of what happened in Korea with what he fears could happen in an equivalent scenario in the US.
Then, for most of yesterday, I was swept up by events in Syria, which are more complex, but which the Syrian democracy activists and journalists of whom I'm aware are fairly unanimous in saying are a very good thing, even if you take the involvement of Islamists and the Turkish government (and the obvious uncertainty now that the regime has been toppled but not yet replaced) into account. I've mostly been following this through accounts on Bluesky (which thankfully can be viewed without signing up), mainly from Syrians who were involved in the initial revolution in their country in the 2010s, and suffered the most appalling consequences when that revolution was crushed, and their various supporters from elsewhere in the world.
One activist, who was imprisoned by the regime in 2011 and has been living in exile since his release, noted that Syrians like him were 'track[ing] the fall of the regime not in cities, but in prisons [of political prisoners] liberated,' which I think says it all.
I hope everyone in my part of the world stayed safe this weekend, and that the consequences of the storm weren't too severe.
I finished another book in my Benjamin January reread, worked on Yuletide stuff, watched biathlon with Matthias, and spent ages writing and replying to long comments on Dreamwidth. It was an utterly lazy Saturday, with no gym (since I hadn't booked the classes in expectation of being in Cambridge during that time), and no time outside the house apart from a quick run to the bakery first thing (before the storm began) to get pastries. By about midday, the storm had arrived in earnest, but it wasn't too bad in this part of the world — just lashing rain, and strong winds. I know my friends in Ireland, Wales, and the west of England had it much worse, including at least one friend in Wales who lost power briefly, but for us in the east, it was basically just a cosy day at home.
The weather's still pretty miserable here, so I'm not planning to do much today — a longer yoga class after I've written this post, a bit more comfort rereading, and slow-cooking tonight's dinner for most of the afternoon. Otherwise, I will carry on what I've also been doing for much of yesterday, and the previous week, which is glue myself to updates and analysis of all the extraordinary political events taking place around the world.
Initially I was keeping a fairly close eye on what was happening in South Korea, Romania and Georgia (the country, not the US state). This Observer editorial is fairly broad-brush and simplistic, but covers the main points, while this longer essay by Timothy Snyder is a rather depressing comparison of what happened in Korea with what he fears could happen in an equivalent scenario in the US.
Then, for most of yesterday, I was swept up by events in Syria, which are more complex, but which the Syrian democracy activists and journalists of whom I'm aware are fairly unanimous in saying are a very good thing, even if you take the involvement of Islamists and the Turkish government (and the obvious uncertainty now that the regime has been toppled but not yet replaced) into account. I've mostly been following this through accounts on Bluesky (which thankfully can be viewed without signing up), mainly from Syrians who were involved in the initial revolution in their country in the 2010s, and suffered the most appalling consequences when that revolution was crushed, and their various supporters from elsewhere in the world.
One activist, who was imprisoned by the regime in 2011 and has been living in exile since his release, noted that Syrians like him were 'track[ing] the fall of the regime not in cities, but in prisons [of political prisoners] liberated,' which I think says it all.
I hope everyone in my part of the world stayed safe this weekend, and that the consequences of the storm weren't too severe.
no subject
Date: 2024-12-08 03:47 pm (UTC)It's been a very interesting few days keeping up with the news! I am intrigued how this may influence America in the coming days, if at all.
no subject
Date: 2024-12-08 04:13 pm (UTC)It's been a very interesting few days keeping up with the news! I am intrigued how this may influence America in the coming days, if at all.
It certainly has! One thing I would like to result from this — although I don't have much hope about it — is for progressive-minded people from the US, and other powerful countries in the west to understand that they can learn a lot from the experiences and actions of people in other countries, especially people whose experience of democracy is still relatively new (such as in South Korea, which has only been a democracy for about 40 years), or where they are still struggling to establish it (such as in Georgia). If we were capable of learning from them, and making similar choices, we would be a lot more capable of facing the threats to our own fragile democracies. They all learn from and help each other: Georgians and Ukrainians have been trading tips on surviving violence at the hands of riot police cracking down on mass protests, Syrians and Ukrainians hold joint events and learn from each other in building civil society resilience and surviving aerial bombardment, and so on. I would like people who come from wealthier, older, more established democracies to have the humility to learn from their example, and to see the connections between their situations and ours.
no subject
Date: 2024-12-08 05:08 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2024-12-08 05:27 pm (UTC)An exchange I saw last night that really typefies this problem: one person posted something to the effect of 'all tyrants eventually fall,' and someone else responded that no, that is not correct. Tyrants do not fall, they are overthrown by the deliberate, conscious, long-term, relentless actions of people. There are situations so dire they people have to act, and sometimes, those people have to be you. (Obviously I don't mean you personally, I mean plural 'you' in a general sense.)
no subject
Date: 2024-12-08 05:44 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2024-12-08 05:58 pm (UTC)I do think the war in Ukraine has also significantly complicated my feelings on Western society and democracy: again, I'm so used to seeing those institutions criticised (and often rightly so), that it was only with the invasion that I really started to see my privilege in living in a free society (and being able to criticise that society!); I think a lot of people who have never lived in actual autocracies struggle to grasp how much worse things could be (which isn't saying, of course, that there isn't a lot that can be done to improve democracies). During the collapse of the USSR, my mum was taking intensive English classes with a university professor, and she mentioned to me a while ago that she was afraid the whole time that she might be identified as a collaborator by the authorities - because even if in hindsight it was clear the USSR was going to collapse, people didn't know it at the time. And from my position, I can't imagine having that kind of fear just from learning a language (and that's really just touching on the tip of the iceberg of my family's experiences)...
no subject
Date: 2024-12-10 05:17 pm (UTC)I do think the war in Ukraine has also significantly complicated my feelings on Western society and democracy: again, I'm so used to seeing those institutions criticised (and often rightly so), that it was only with the invasion that I really started to see my privilege in living in a free society (and being able to criticise that society!); I think a lot of people who have never lived in actual autocracies struggle to grasp how much worse things could be (which isn't saying, of course, that there isn't a lot that can be done to improve democracies).
Yes, this has very much been my trajectory as well. This doesn't mean that we (in the UK for example) should just sit back and assume that because we have it better than those living in autocracies, we don't need to do anything to maintain this state of affairs or improve things locally, but it does mean to have a sense of proportion, and try to pick your battles, rather than reacting to every single thing. And to be really clear that citizenship of a democracy doesn't just mean coming out of your box every three-five years to make a mark on an election ballot and then go back to sleep again: politics is something you do every day, and being an active citizen is like the rent you pay for the unearned good fortune of living in a democracy.
no subject
Date: 2024-12-09 02:51 pm (UTC)Back when I worked with non-profits (pre-covid), I listened to a podcast about healthcare in West Africa and the innovations there: cheap, nimble, effective. One part of the discussion was about the U.S. Could our providers learn from their providers? Of course. Did they? No. And why? Because it was AFRICA, what could we possibly learn from folks over there?!?! Sigh...
I also fear that Americans are too used to our civic participation consisting of voting (if we feel sufficiently moved to) or blithering on social media. We don't know how to organize for the long term; we better learn quick.
no subject
Date: 2024-12-10 05:22 pm (UTC)I also fear that Americans are too used to our civic participation consisting of voting (if we feel sufficiently moved to) or blithering on social media. We don't know how to organize for the long term; we better learn quick.
This is not just limited to Americans, and it's something I've been concerned about for a really long time. The people I know living in war zones and countries at risk of autocracy are extremely good at a) horizonal organisation and coalition building, and b) being really, really persistent and committed to staying in the fight for the long term. These two things do a lot to maintain their resilience and adaptability to changing (including worsening) circumstances, and they are the two things above all that I wish citizens of wealthy, older democracies were capable of learning from them.
no subject
Date: 2024-12-09 01:30 am (UTC)I wrote out a whole long thing about the political situations around the world and have simply deleted it. It's always good, though, to see your level-headed thoughts about world events.
no subject
Date: 2024-12-10 05:28 pm (UTC)Blissful freedom! oh, I love that for you and want it for me.
I want it for you too!
no subject
Date: 2024-12-09 03:43 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2024-12-10 05:29 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2024-12-10 07:13 pm (UTC)